question In Detail . (5 Marks)

Question

Explain the importance of each statement of Panchavyavi conjecture.

Vidyadip · Accepted Answer

* The conjecture made by Indian logicians is called 'Indian conjecture'. * Since the literal representation of Indian conjecture consists of five components, it is called 'Panchavayavi conjecture'. Indian Panchayavi estimates. Sr. No Name Examples 1. Pledge It is a fire on the mountain. 2. Purpose Because, it's smoke on the mountain. ૩. Scope including example Where there is smoke There is fire. E.g. In the kitchen 4. Upanay Relation to fire the smoldering smoke is on that mountain. 5. Incorporation So it is fire on the mountain. * Importance of each statement of Panchavayavi conjecture: 1. Pledge: The statement which represents the knowledge which is to be proved to be true through conjecture is called pledge. * The Panchavayavi conjecture is a literal representation of the conjecture made by the speaker to the listener. * Conclusion by conjecture. What is extracted is presented in advance to the listener; So that the listener can evaluate it. * It is psychologically and logically useful to state the results in advance. * In the above example, the speaker tells the listener from the very beginning that I want to prove that ‘it is a fire on the mountain’. 2. Purpose: Guess action can only be initiated if the judges know that there is a presence in the party of the purpose. * ‘Purpose’ tells the listener that the purpose is to be present in order to prove Sadhya’s presence in the party. So the conjecture can be advanced in action. * In the above example, the motto 'It is smoke on the mountain' is introduced so that 'it is fire on the mountain' may result. * Thus, the purpose-sentence is of logical importance. 3. Scope including example: According to the opinion of the jurists, it is necessary to confirm the scope of the scope between the purpose and the achievable after the party has a direct knowledge of the purpose. * By scope, including the example, the speaker tells the listener by example that there is a relation between the purpose and the accomplishment. * In the example above, the speaker introduces the scope including the example and tells the listener that the statement ‘it is fire on the mountain’ can be proved; Because smoke appears on the mountain. The phrase ‘where there is smoke there is fire’ is derived from observing examples such as kitchens. 4. Upanay: This fourth component of the Panchavayavi conjecture is called Upanay because it takes the listener to the result. * In this example, the speaker introduces a subtext to the listener, saying, "It is a fire on a mountain." * Complete proof of Result Statement is found through Upanay. 5. Incorporation: The fourth line of the Panchavayavi conjecture, through the subjunctive, the speaker has assured the listener that there is a presence in the party of the intended purpose which is related to the sadhya. * Based on this conviction, the resultant statement derived from the logically correct inference of such knowledge obtained by inference is represented by the corporation. * In the example above, the speaker tells the listener that the smoke that pervades the fire is on the mountain. * Therefore, the knowledge that we get through the inference of the resultant statement that ‘it is fire on the mountain’ proves that the knowledge is the true knowledge free from doubt and delusion.

Answer

Need a full question paper?

Explore more

Similar questions

Sr. No	Name	Examples
$1.$	Pledge	It is a fire on the mountain.
$2.$	Purpose	Because, it's smoke on the mountain.
$૩.$	Scope including example	Where there is smoke There is fire. E.g. In the kitchen
$4.$	Upanay	Relation to fire the smoldering smoke is on that mountain.
$5.$	Incorporation	So it is fire on the mountain.

Guessing in Indian Logic — Philosophy STD 12 Arts — Question

Answer

Need a full question paper?

Explore more

Similar questions